Skip to main content

Singing while you walk and learning to communicate between the towers of academia

Émile Jaques-Dalcroze

As a geriatrician and an ethnomusicologist, I have had ample opportunity to observe the impact of music upon gait among my patients. Whether singing “Tumbalalaika” in order to help a Parkinsonian patient avoid freezing on a threshold, or singing “Won’t You Come Home, Bill Bailey,” in order to help someone with dementia get up and walk to the dining hall, I have watched as halting, shuffling gaits develop a steady rhythm. In each case, the patient begins to walk in synchrony with the song and the caregiver.

It was with delight, therefore, that I read the article by Trombetti, et al., in the upcoming issue of the Archives of Internal Medicine. They have taken such anecdotal experiences and subjected them to the rigors of the randomized clinical trial. Powered to detect measurable differences in gait, they have demonstrated in medical parlance what many of us have seen, that gait can improve with music.

Trombetti and colleagues offer us an interesting piece of information: that community-dwelling elders can have improved ability to ambulate when their steps are accompanied by piano music. They used Jacques-Dalcroze Eurythmics (an established music pedagogical approach that was developed in the late 19th century) in a 12 month-long RCT involving 134 community dwelling elders and an accepted research methodology. For the first time it has been shown, they say, “that participation in music-based multitask exercise classes once a week over a 6-month period can improve gait performance…and reduce both the rate of falls and the risk of falling in at-risk elderly community-dwelling adults” (online advance publication, November 22, 2010, p. E7).

It’s a great article, accepted in a highly reputable medical journal. My only question: where’s the music?

For the most part the authors appropriately cite the handful of music therapy articles that deal with gait. It's a shame, though, that they miss Alicia Ann Clair’s interesting work on rhythmic-auditory-stimulation (RAS). In one of the rare “negative finding” publications, she demonstrated that RAS did not lead to a significant difference in gait, but discovered that the caregivers involved in the study reported that ambulating a patient seemed easier when the music was playing.

The inclusion of music therapy literature in a medical journal is important here. There is more, however, to music research than music therapy and music’s therapeutic value. In the fields of ethnomusicology, music education (the academic home of Dalcroze Eurythmics), pscyhomusicology, psychology, neurology, gerontologic nursing, and geriatrics, some of us examine the music itself as well as its habilitative and rehabilitative effects. There is even a new analogue to medical anthropology, called medical ethnomusicology, which is devoted to issues of music, culture, health and healing.

As a musicologist, I would like to hear more about the music chosen in these sessions. Was it all improvised? And if so, how was the give-and-take established between the instructor and students? Were there direct musical references to melodies from childhood? Were there performances of familiar songs? Did the choice of music make a difference in its efficacy? It is unreasonable to ask a group of physicians and researchers to take an article this far in the Archives. But it is absolutely reasonable to begin a conversation.

Now is the time for each of us to step outside of our academic silos, following in the footsteps of Trombetti and colleagues. They have built a bridge between geriatric falls prevention and music education in order to keep older people from falling. Our older patients will benefit from this stretch between the disciplines.

Reaching out across disciplines brings a multi-faceted understanding of the problems, and a better understanding of potential solutions. Will I be able to start a Dalcroze school at the nursing home where I practice? No. But I will feel more confident as I continue to encourage my patients to sing as they walk. And I would be delighted to start building more bridges across the academy.

_________________

Trombetti, A; Hars, M.; Herrmann, FR; Kressig, RW; Ferrari, S; Rizzoli, R. Effect of Music-Based Multitask Training on Gait, Balance and Fall Risk in Elderly People. Archives of Internal Medicine. Published online November 22, 2010. http://www.archinternmed.com/

by: Theresa Allison

Comments

Anonymous said…
Coincidentally, here are two recent related publications - a book review of "The Music Instinct: How Music Works and Why We Can’t Do Without It" by Philip Ball at BMJ 2010; 341:c6965 doi: 10.1136/bmj.c6965 (Published 8 December 2010) & an essay entitled "Music for healing: from magic to medicine" in The Lancet, Volume 376, Issue 9757, Pages 1980 - 1981, 11 December 2010.

Our palliative care service in Canada hired a music therapist several years ago who has proved to be a very valuable and skilful team member.

Its interesting to see research on music entering the mainstream.

Paul McIntyre

Popular posts from this blog

Lost in Translation: Google’s Translation of Palliative Care to ‘Do-Nothing Care’

by: Cynthia X. Pan, MD, FACP, AGSF (@Cxpan5X)

My colleagues often ask me: “Why are Chinese patients so resistant to hospice and palliative care?” “Why are they so unrealistic?” “Don’t they understand that death is part of life?” “Is it true that with Chinese patients you cannot discuss advance directives?”

As a Chinese speaking geriatrician and palliative care physician practicing in Flushing, NY, I have cared for countless Chinese patients with serious illnesses or at end of life.  Invariably, when Chinese patients or families see me, they ask me if I speak Chinese. When I reply “I do” in Mandarin, the relief and instant trust I see on their faces make my day meaningful and worthwhile.

At my hospital, the patient population is about 30% Asian, with the majority of these being Chinese. Most of these patients require language interpretation.  It becomes an interesting challenge and opportunity, as we often need to discuss advance directives, goals of care, and end of life care options…

Are Palliative Care Providers Better Prognosticators? A Podcast with Bob Gramling

Estimating prognosis is hard and clinicians get very little training on how to do it.  Maybe that is one of the reasons that clinicians are more likely to be optimistic and tend to overestimate patient survival by a factor of between 3 and 5.  The question is, aren't we better as palliative care clinicians than others in estimating prognosis?  This is part of our training and we do it daily.   We got to be better, right? 

Well, on todays podcast we have Bob Gramling from the Holly and Bob Miller Chair of Palliative Medicine at the University of Vermont to talk about his paper in Journal of Pain and Symptom Management (JPSM) titled “Palliative Care Clinician Overestimation of Survival in Advanced Cancer: Disparities and Association with End of Life Care”.

Big findings from this JPSM paper include that we, like all other clinicians, are an optimistic bunch and that it actually does impact outcomes.   In particular, the people whose survival was overestimated by a palliative care c…

Delirium: A podcast with Sharon Inouye

In this week's GeriPal podcast we discuss delirium, with a focus on prevention. We are joined by internationally acclaimed delirium researcher Sharon Inouye, MD, MPH. Dr Inouye is Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School and Director of the Aging Brain Center in the Institute for Aging Research at Hebrew SeniorLife.

Dr. Inouye's research focuses on delirium and functional decline in hospitalized older patients, resulting in more than 200 peer-reviewed original articles to date. She has developed and validated a widely used tool to identify delirium called the Confusion Assessment Method (CAM), and she founded the Hospital Elder Life Program (HELP) to prevent delirium in hospitalized patients.

We are also joined by guest host Lindsey Haddock, MD, a geriatrics fellow at UCSF who asks a great question about how to implement a HELP program, or aspects of the program, in a hospital with limited resources.  


You can also find us on Youtube!


Listen to GeriPal Podcasts on:
iTunes…