Skip to main content

Screening for Elder Abuse and Neglect – the USPSTF Report


The United States Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) released its updated standards for screening older or physically or mentally dysfunctional adults for abuse and neglect. The conclusion? “Recommendation I - current evidence is insufficient to assess the balance of benefits and harms of the service.”

What does this mean? There are varying interpretations – but the wrong interpretation is that we should forego screening for abuse and neglect in vulnerable older patients. As the CDC report notes, few studies have evaluated the accuracy and outcomes of specific screening strategies in older adults. Yet elder abuse in its various forms affects in the range of 2% to well above 10% of older adults. This can include physical, psychological, or sexual abuse, financial exploitation, and neglect. One study found that 1 in 10 older adults may have been abused, yet only 1 in 5 of these cases were reported.

No doubt there are potential harms of screening for elder abuse, such as shame, guilt, retaliation, and the unnecessary turmoil caused by false-positive results. Yet while strong evidence on this topic is limited, existing reports suggest that the risk of such harms might be small.

Where to next? My own practice is (or at least aspires) to follow the recommendations in an excellent recent review by Mosqueda and Dong. They recommend identifying risk factors for abuse or neglect such as cognitive or physical impairment, low degrees of social support, and aggressive behaviors. They recommend carefully observing for signs of abuse or neglect, include indications that the patient is fearful of the caregiver, injuries in unusual locations or with inadequate explanations, and changes in behavior such as missing appointments or decreasing standards of hygiene. Finally, they recommend asking the patient (and caregiver, where appropriate) simple, direct questions:

  •  Has anybody hurt you? 
  • Are you afraid of anybody?
  • Are your mom’s needs more than you are able to handle?
  • Are you worried that you might hit your mom?” 

 by: Mike Steinman

Comments

Anonymous said…
Elder abuse is a serious and growing concern in both long-term care facilities as well as private homes. We would greatly encourage readers to check out this review by Hollie Caldwell, PhD, Elder Abuse Screening Instruments in Primary Care: An Integrative Review, 2004 to 2011 [http://www.clinicalgeriatrics.com/articles/Elder-Abuse-Screening-Instruments-Primary-Care-Integrative-Review-2004-2011.] We also recommend this tip sheet, which provides advice for preventing abuse and neglect in older adults. [http://www.clinicalgeriatrics.com/files/elder_abuse_tips.pdf.]
Richard said…
Most older people are not experiencing abuse. But, unfortunately, there are ways in which an older person can be harmed or abused by others. An older person may also experience more than one form of abuse at any given time. Government and NGO's should work hand-in-hand to overcome this problem. Don't forget that every person will become old at one stage. So respect your elder people.
helen zoya said…
Today elder abuse is continually increasing and has become one of serious problems in our society. In the survey it has been found that the majority of elder abuse victims are female. It is seriously a big shame on our society. People don’t want to live with their old parents and their why they have to take aid of old age homes.
Home Help for elderly

Popular posts from this blog

Nowhere Else to Be

The following story is by Jennifer Heidmann, MD, FACP. She is the Medical Director of Redwood Coast PACE in Eureka, CA, as well as a physician for Hospice of Humboldt and a hospitalist at St Joseph Hospital.

Managing Behavioral Symptoms in Dementia: Podcast with Helen Kales

In this week's podcast we talk with Helen Kales, Professor of Psychiatry at the University of Michigan the VA Center for Clinical Management and Research. 

We've spent a great deal of effort in Geriatrics describing what we shouldn't do to address behavioral symptoms in dementia: physical restraints, antipsychotics, sedating antidepressants.  Helen Kales was lecturing around the country about all of these things we shouldn't do a few years back, and people would raise their hands and ask, "Well, what should we do?" She realized she needed to give caregivers tools to help.

Churning Patients Through the End of Life: A Podcast with Joan Teno

On this weeks podcast, we interview Dr. Joan Teno about her recently published study in JAMA titled "Site of Death, Place of Care, and Health Care Transitions Among US Medicare Beneficiaries, 2000-2015."

In 2013, Dr. Teno published a study that showed how good our health care system in the US promotes patient churn. Despite positive signs of more hospice use and decreased deaths in the hospital, Dr. Teno found the from 2000 to 2009 we "churned" patients through more ICU visits, more hospitalizations, and more late transitions that are burdensome to dying persons in their family. Dr. Teno's latest study shows us how we are doing now, extending that work to 2015 and now including Medicare Advantage (MA) plans.