Skip to main content

Dying without Dialysis



There is a terrific article in this weeks Journal of Pain and Symptom Management by Fliss Murtagh of King's College in London about the epidemiology of symptoms for patients with advanced renal failure who die without dialysis.  This study is important because while we know that patients with advanced renal failure have a limited life expectancy and the average age of initiation of hemodialysis is increasing, we know little about the alternatives to hemodialysis.  Specifically, we know nothing about symptoms affecting quality of life among patients who elect not to start dialysis (so called "conservative management" - is this the best label?).  This article provides a terrific counterpoint to the article in last years NEJM showing that nursing home residents who initiated hemodialysis tended to die and decline in function (see GeriPal write up here). 

The study authors followed patients with the most advanced form of chronic kidney disease (the new name for renal failure).  These patients had a GFR of <15 and are typically referred for dialysis.  This study focused on the symptom experience in the last month of life for the 49 patients who elected not to initiate hemodialysis and died over the course of the study.  Symptom prevalence in the last month of life:
  • 42% experienced lack of energy
  • 41% itching
  • 40% feeling drowsy
  • 39% shortness of breath
  • 37% difficulty concentrating
  • 36% pain
  • 35% lack of appetite
  • 35% swelling of arms/legs
How do these symptoms compare to the prevalence of symptoms in patients with advanced cancer?  The authors nicely make this comparison for us.  They do note that there are relatively few studies of symptom prevalence in the last month or fortnight of life, even for patients with advanced cancer.  This caused me to a) chuckle "oh, the Brits" and b) google "fortnight" - it means two weeks.  Back to the comparison:
  • patients dying of renal failure without hemodialysis were more likely to experience itching, drowsiness, and dyspnea in the last month of life than patients with advanced cancer
  • prevalence of lack of energy, pain, and lack of appetite are similar
What are the clinical implications and remaining questions?
  • I usually tell patients and family members that dying of renal failure is "peaceful."  I say, "you generally become more and more drowsy, and drift off into a sleep from which you don't wake."  This article challenges those words.  While I think the final hours and days may resemble that trajectory, the last month as a whole is actually a time of relatively high symptom burden.  Clinicians should attend to these symptoms as aggressively as they do for patients with advanced cancer.
  • The degree to which these symptoms were due to renal failure or co-morbid conditions is not clear.  These patients were not young healthy folks who refused hemodialysis, they refused because they were elderly (mean age at death 81) and had a high burden of chronic conditions like heart failure.  Comorbid conditions may be as great a source of suffering in the elderly as the terminal condition (a very Geriatric perspective). 
  • We still have no randomized controlled trial of hemodialysis vs. no hemodialysis for elderly patients with multiple chronic conditions.  We don't know if "conservative management" (no dialysis) is actually associated with a shorter time to death as is widely assumed.  We don't know if hemodialysis is associated with a greater burden of suffering, or if (maybe) the trade-offs in terms of reduction in swelling and shortness of breath by using dialysis are worth the hassle, risks, and time spent hooked up to the machine. 
Please comment!

by: Alex Smith

Comments

Anonymous said…
We just discussed a patient at hospice team today who has been enrolled for 6 months with end-stage renal disease. She does not want dialysis and wishes to remain on hospice. Without symptoms we are struggling to decide about her prognosis and hospice eligibility. We will likely see more people like her moving forward.
Anonymous said…
I'm going to start using fortnight instead of "biweekly" from now on. Thank you geripal.
Eric Widera said…
I'm still trying to figure out what to do with this data. What would be helpful to me is to see how this compares to patients on dialysis as I don't think the prevalence of these symptoms would be any better if they chose to be hooked up to the HD machine (I think itching has been quoted as high as 60% of HD patients, and fatigue/pain are incredibly common).

What seems clear from your post is the symptom needs are very high at the end of life. I wonder if anyone is looking at this population for an outpatient palliative care intervention like Temel and colleagues looked at the metastatic lung population?
Ajanta said…
Hi - I'm a paediatrician but have interested to read this forum as my grandmother in Bangladesh who is 86 has been recently started on dialysis for ESRF. Unfortunately in that country the concepts behind palliative care are not well developed and the tendency is for treatment always to be aggressive. I am also interested in finding out how much difference the dialysis will make to her life expectancy - does anyone have any experience of its use in the this age group? Currently as I understand it, my grandmother does not want the dialysis but is not being given the option by her family, partly due to unrealistic advice from the doctors over there. I would be grateful for any information/advice
Alex Klatt said…
So without kidney dialysis, you die within one year?

Popular posts from this blog

The Dangers of Fleet Enemas

The dangers of oral sodium phosphate preparations are fairly well known in the medical community. In 2006 the FDA issued it’s first warning that patients taking oral sodium phosphate preparations are at risk for potential for acute kidney injury. Two years later, over-the-counter preparations of these drugs were voluntarily withdrawn by the manufacturers.  Those agents still available by prescription were given black box warnings mainly due to acute phosphate nephropathy that can result in renal failure, especially in older adults. Despite all this talk of oral preparations, little was mentioned about a sodium phosphate preparation that is still available over-the-counter – the Fleet enema.

Why Oral Sodium Phosphate Preparations Are Dangerous 

Before we go into the risks of Fleet enemas, lets spend just a couple sentences on why oral sodium phosphate preparations carry significant risks. First, oral sodium phosphate preparations can cause significant fluid shifts within the colon …

Does “compassionate deception” have a place in palliative care?

by: Olivia Gamboa (@Liv_g_g)

There is broad consensus in the medical community that lying to patients is unethical.  However, in the care of patients with dementia, the moral clarity of this approach blurs.  In her recent New Yorker article, “The Memory House,”  Larissa MacFarquhar provides an excellent portrait of the common devices of artifice, omission and outright deception that are frequently deployed in the care of patients with dementia.  She furthermore explores the historical and ethical underpinnings of the various approaches used in disclosing (or not) information to patients living with dementia.

Ms. MacFarquhar introduces the idea of “compassionate deception,” or the concept that withholding truths, or even promoting outright falsehoods, is a reasonable and even ethical choice for those caring for patients with dementia.  To the extent that it helps a person with dementia feel happier and calmer, allowing them to believe in a gentler reality (one in which, say, their spo…